Best places to open a thrift store in Long Island (Suffolk County), NY

We scored 8,918 zones across Long Island (Suffolk County) (hexagons about 350 m / 0.2 mi wide) for a thrift store, combining foot traffic, residents, workers, household income and nearby competition. 2,461 zones score 70 or higher. Data updated November 18, 2026.

8,918zones scored
2,461strong zones (70+)
96/100top zone score
211competing businesses in Long Island (Suffolk County)
≈ $5,500/moest. rent, 1,500 sq ft in Brentwood, Suffolk County

Top 10 areas for a thrift store in Long Island (Suffolk County)

Each area is ranked by its best-scoring zone. Competitors are counted within ~400 m of that zone.

#AreaBest zoneCompetitorsFoot trafficMedian incomeEst. rentZones 70+
1Brentwood, Suffolk County
96
0100/100—$44/sq ft/yr97 of 198
2West Islip, Suffolk County
96
097/100$188,056$44/sq ft/yr81 of 124
3Bay Shore, Suffolk County
96
0100/100$110,694$44/sq ft/yr79 of 130
4Huntington Station, Suffolk County
96
0100/100$146,270$44/sq ft/yr70 of 129
5Lindenhurst, Suffolk County
96
098/100$156,006$44/sq ft/yr68 of 89
6Smithtown, Suffolk County
96
098/100$144,615$44/sq ft/yr63 of 179
7East Islip, Suffolk County
96
098/100$151,011$44/sq ft/yr43 of 74
8Greenlawn, Suffolk County
96
095/100$182,283$43/sq ft/yr41 of 67
9Copiague, Suffolk County
96
099/100$144,026$44/sq ft/yr40 of 76
10East Northport, Suffolk County
96
096/100$168,056$44/sq ft/yr32 of 104

Why these areas stand out

  1. Brentwood, Suffolk County — the best zone scores 96/100, with a foot-traffic index of 100/100 and no competing businesses within ~400 m. 97 zones in this area score 70+.
  2. West Islip, Suffolk County — the best zone scores 96/100, with a foot-traffic index of 97/100 and no competing businesses within ~400 m; median household income nearby is $188,056. 81 zones in this area score 70+.
  3. Bay Shore, Suffolk County — the best zone scores 96/100, with a foot-traffic index of 100/100 and no competing businesses within ~400 m; median household income nearby is $110,694. 79 zones in this area score 70+.

What makes a good location for a thrift store

For a thrift store, the strongest demand signal is busy commercial streets where people already go to shop and eat (28% of the demand estimate), followed by commuter flow — people walking to and from nearby transit stations (20%). Demand is then weighed against competing businesses within about 400 m.

Street activity28%
Transit riders20%
Residents nearby20%
Household income20%
Daytime workers12%

Share of each factor in the demand estimate for this business type. Typical space: 1,500 sq ft (≈ 139 m²). How the score works →

What we count as competition

When we score a location for a thrift store, these kinds of places within about 400 m count as competitors: Antiques, Second-hand store, Vintage clothing. Places marked as permanently closed are not counted — they are shown separately on the map.

See the exact blocks, not just the neighborhood

BizChecker scores every zone in Long Island (Suffolk County) on an interactive map — competitors, transit, closed businesses and rent estimates — and turns any spot into a PDF report you can share.

Check a location →

Questions

What is the best area to open a thrift store in Long Island (Suffolk County)?
By BizChecker data (updated November 18, 2026), the highest-scoring area is Brentwood, Suffolk County (96/100), followed by West Islip, Suffolk County and Bay Shore, Suffolk County. Scores combine foot traffic, residents, workers, income and nearby competition.
How much competition is there for a thrift store in Long Island (Suffolk County)?
We count about 211 businesses that compete with a thrift store across Long Island (Suffolk County). Another 9 similar places are marked as permanently closed in our sources.
How much does retail space cost in Brentwood, Suffolk County?
Estimated asking rent in the top zone of Brentwood, Suffolk County is about $44 per sq ft per year — roughly $5,500 a month for a typical 1,500 sq ft space. It is an estimate based on broker reports, not a quote.
What matters most when choosing a location for a thrift store?
For a thrift store, the strongest demand signal is busy commercial streets where people already go to shop and eat (28% of the demand estimate), followed by commuter flow — people walking to and from nearby transit stations (20%). Demand is then weighed against competing businesses within about 400 m.

Best U.S. cities to open a thrift store →

How the score works

Each zone is a hexagon about 350 m (0.2 mi) across. For every zone we estimate demand — foot traffic (transit stations, residents, workers), household income — and weigh it against competition from similar businesses within ~400 m. The result is a score from 0 to 100. Parks, water, airports and industrial land are left out.

Sources: U.S. Census Bureau (2020 Census, American Community Survey 5-year), LEHD LODES, Overture Maps Foundation places (© Overture Maps Foundation, CDLA-Permissive-2.0), broker rent reports. This product uses the Census Bureau Data API but is not endorsed or certified by the Census Bureau.

Scores are statistical estimates from public data, not a guarantee of success or financial advice. Visit the location, check zoning and permits, and talk to a broker before signing a lease.

Other businesses in Long Island (Suffolk County)

Thrift store locations in other New York areas